TLDR; If you’re in a hurry the BedInABox Original Original Mattress is the Best Bed in a Box according to Reddit! Get it with No gimmicks, no sales tactics, 120 night trial & easy returns
Save up to 20% on Bedinabox mattresses
“Bed in a box” type mattresses have become extremely popular over the past few decades. If you didn’t know, bed in a box mattresses are mattresses that arrive in a box for easy shipment. This saves your effort and time which might have otherwise been wasted at several mattress stores, with you never being able to get a well suited mattress.
Bed in a box mattresses arrive in a compressed condition, with all the air sucked out of them so that they can fit in a box. Such mattresses take some time to fully expand to their normal size after being set up.
What you should look for in a Bed In A Box
CertiPUR-US is a non-profit certification program which tests and certifies foam. CertiPUR-US certified foam mattresses have these 6 important features:
- They are free of ozone depleting chemicals like chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs).
- They do not use PBDEs (polybrominated diphenyl ethers), TCEP (tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine), and TDCPP (Tris(1,3-dichloroisopropyl)phosphate). All of these chemicals have been/continue to be used as flame retardants in some mattresses. PBDEs are harmful to the environment and have been banned by the Environmental Protection Agency. TCEP and TDCPP are harmful to the body, and may cause cancer, genetic effects, low fertility, or damage to an unborn child.
- They don’t have any heavy metals like mercury or lead. Heavy metal poisoning can be extremely dangerous.
- They are made without Formaldehyde.
- They are not made of prohibited phthalates, which are especially harmful to children.
- They emit low amounts of volatile organic compounds (VOCs). You’ll often see people talk about “off gassing” in mattresses. This “off gassing” is caused by the release of VOCs, especially when the mattress is new. These compounds emit an uncomfortable odor, and some of them may be harmful in the case of long term exposure. Therefore, it’s important to keep them at a minimum.
Perforated foam or gel infusion
Memory foam mattresses are notorious for their property of trapping heat. However, your mattress trapping heat is not a good thing most of the time. It prevents you from cooling down and may cause discomfort due to the heat. This may, in turn, disrupt your sleep pattern and/or your sleep quality. Make sure your memory foam mattress is either gel infused or perforated for adequate airflow to keep you cool.
Motion transfer resistance
Resistance to motion transfer is extremely important, especially if you have a pet or sleep with your partner. Your partner (or your pet) moving should not set movements across the entire mattress. Poor resistance to motion transfer would lead to your side of the mattress moving because the other person is also moving. This may disrupt sleep, or lead to poor quality sleep in general. Choose a mattress which has a high resistance to motion transfer. Memory foam mattresses in general perform better in this regard.
Never buy a mattress without proper warranty. Although some brands are specifically bad in handling quality control issues, any brand can ship a defective mattress. In many cases the slight manufacturing defects may not be visible outright, and may only start to show observable effects after a couple of years. A warranty of 10 years is the industry standard, and you should make sure you’re getting that warranty just in case something goes wrong. Mattresses are expensive, especially the premium ones. You wouldn’t want to waste your money on a bad mattress that you would have to throw away later. Warranty ensures that the company either repairs or replaces your mattress in case of any damage or defect covered under the warranty claims. Always buy from an authorized seller, and buy new mattresses so that you get the warranty along with the mattress. Buying from unauthorized retailers often voids the warranty.
What you should avoid in a Bed In a Box
Avoid buying a mattress that contains fiberglass. Memory foam mattresses are highly flammable in nature, and therefore need to be protected with a flame retardant. Cheaper mattress manufacturers often use fiberglass as a flame retardant for memory foam mattresses. However, over the years, normal wear and tear exposes you to fiberglass shards, which may cause severe itching and breathing issues. This is not just limited to your mattress: it spreads everywhere around your house by air. Fiberglass contamination is quite difficult to clean, and spreads rather quickly. Some people have had to get special cleaning services to get rid of fiberglass contamination. Avoid mattress brands like Zinus, as they are well known for using fiberglass in their mattresses. If you do buy a mattress with fiberglass, make sure that you don’t remove the mattress cover, or else the fiberglass may spread leading to contamination.
With that said, here’s a list of the best bed in a box mattresses you can get:
Best Bed in A Box Reddit
1. BedInABox Original Mattress – Best Bed In A Box According to Reddit
- Relatively affordable
- Warranty of 20 years
- 120 nights trial period
- Non removable cover
Funnily enough, the brand that takes the first position in our list of best bed in a box mattresses is simply BedInABox. BedInABox sells 6 mattresses in total: the BedInABox Original, BedInABox Tranquillium, BedInABox Azul, BedInABox Dual Hybrid, and BedInABox Eco-lux. Out of these, BedInABox has two bestselling memory foam mattresses: the cheaper BedInABox Original, and the slightly more expensive BedInABox Tranquillium.
Both of them are gel-infused memory foam mattresses. They come with a warranty of 20 years and a trial period of 120 nights. Both the mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified. The company advises you to avoid removing the cover, making it clear that the cover is not meant to be unzipped or removed.
The cheaper mattress, BedInABox Original, is 11 inches thick. It starts at $599 (Twin), and goes up to $953 (Cal. King). It comes in 6 sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King. The Twin size version weighs 53 pounds while the California King version weighs 110 pounds. Although not the lightest, this mattress is relatively light compared to other mattresses in this list, especially the hybrid ones. Lighter mattresses are easier to set up and move later, so that helps. The mattress has 2 foam layers: an 8 inch support layer at the bottom and a 3 inch comfort layer at the top. The support layer is made of high density foam to provide support to your spine and for the structural reliability of the mattress, while the comfort layer is made of gel-infused memory foam that adjusts itself to the shape of your body and gives you a comfortable, cool feel. The mattress is medium-firm. It’s wrapped in a smooth, circular knit cover.
One thing you might need to consider is that a lot of people have found the mattress to be firmer than expected. Even though the mattress is labeled medium-firm, the mattress is slightly firmer than other such “medium-firm” mattresses. If you prefer a firm memory foam mattress, the BedInABox Original may be the perfect mattress for you. However, if you’re coming from an innerspring mattress and prefer a firm memory foam mattress, the BedInABox Tranquillium, described next in this article, may be a better option.
The mattress lacks proper edge support due to just two layers of memory foam, and a relatively thin comfort layer. Therefore, if you sleep on one of the sides of the mattress, or if you have the habit of rolling in sleep, this mattress may not be ideal for you. Note that a lack of proper edge support means you can easily roll over and fall while trying to get in or out of the bed if you aren’t careful.
- Relatively affordable.
- Industry leading 20 years warranty
- Comfortable cover.
- Lightweight, which makes it easier to move your bed.
- It may be too firm for some individuals.
- Lack of proper edge support.
“I have bought three beds from Bed-in-a-Box. The first one was their base model, and the second two are these.
We bought the first one in a queen, and loved it so much that when we moved and had enough room for a king size bed, we bought another. I cannot say enough about how much I love my bed.
They do sleep warm. I always have to keep a fan on me, even in the winter, but I’m always hot anyway. My husband, on the other hand, loves that it is warmer.” -u/Archivista00
“I got a Bed in a Box about 6 years ago and it’s still my favorite mattress. We bought a second one 2 years ago and it’s hard as hell (despite us ordering their softest model). The new mattress is now on our guest bed and we sleep on the old one. Probably not gonna risk buying from them again cause they’re not cheap and now I can’t trust what I’m going to get.” -u/adenocard
“I have a shoulder replacement and have had three massive rotator cuff tears. I can’t handle super firm mattresses because of this (I’m a side sleeper) even memory foam. We got the basic model memory foam mattress from bedinabox.com (back then it was the only option) about 10 years ago and it’s still perfect. It’s supportive but not HARD you know?” -u/KraftyPants
“I also have a 100% memory foam mattress. I had one for 6 years and just upgraded to the same mattress but in a king instead of a queen… because I loved it so much. I wiggle a lot at night (the mattress helps with pain but doesn’t fix everything) and I don’t disturb my husband with my wiggles. Hybrid mattresses still transfer motion, so those didn’t work for us.
I shopped EVERY mattress out there, (sleep number, Casper, tempurpedic, Serta, etc) but it’s such a personal thing that you’ll have to try beds out for yourself. I went with bedinabox.com (again) because the only bed that I found as comfortable as the one I had was a $7000+ tempurpedic.
I also bought an adjustable frame, and I LOVE it…. Especially on the bad pain days when I can barely leave the bed.
If there is one thing I’ve learned from my extensive research on beds.. it’s that a firmer mattress does NOT equal a more supportive mattress.
I do use a 3 inch gel memory foam topper on my side of the bed (husband is a side sleeper, while I’m back and tummy… so the bed can’t be as insanely marshmallow squishy as I’d like).” -u/SeaShantyOphira
2. BedInABox Tranquillium – The Runner Up
- The higher end flagship mattress from BedInABox
- Warranty of 20 years
- 120 nights trial period
- Non removable cover
- Good back support
- Soft knit Tencel cover
The BedInABox Tranquillium is a more premium version of the BedInABox Original. The BedInABox Tranquillium is also slightly more expensive, starting at $799 (Twin), and going up to $1359 (Cal. King). It is 12 inches thick. It comes in 6 sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King. The Twin size version weighs 53 pounds while the California King version weighs 113 pounds.
The mattress has three foam layers: a 7 inch support layer at the bottom, a 2 inch transition layer in the middle, and a 3 inch comfort layer at the top. The support layer is again made of high density polyurethane foam. It provides great edge support, which ensures you don’t roll out of bed when sleeping on one of the sides. The transition layer is made of PluraLux foam. PluraLux foam is a type of high density polyurethane foam that has a very good level of responsiveness, which makes it ideal as a cushioning layer for maximum comfort. Finally, on the top, we have a 3 inch comfort layer, made of open cell gel-infused memory foam. The mattress is firm. The presence of a transition layer, and the mattress being an all foam mattress in general, makes it highly resistant to motion transfer.
It is covered with a soft knit Tencel cover, which has some really appreciable moisture management properties. Tencel is an older name of Lyocell, which is a synthetic fabric with around 50% more absorbent than cotton. It is also softer than cotton, and is biodegradable just like cotton. It’s one of the most sustainable fabrics in the textile industry.
The company advises you to use a waterproof mattress protector for the mattress, since the mattress cover that comes with the mattress is not supposed to be removed and isn’t washable. If something happens to the mattress cover by any chance, the company advises you to spot clean it with a “mild household fabric” or an upholstery cleaner. The company advises against using rough, thick bristled brushes to scrub the mattress as it may damage the fabric in the cover.
The mattress comes with an unusually long warranty of 20 years, which is very impressive. Most other mattress brands only provide a warranty of 10 years, for perspective. You also get a trial period of 120 nights. If you don’t like it, you can return and get a refund. The mattress is CertiPUR-US certified, and is therefore free of harmful chemicals.
- Good base support and durability.
- High quality mattress cover.
- The Tranquillium features a transition layer for better responsiveness.
- Gel infused.
- A long warranty period of 20 years.
- It may be too firm for some people.
“I purchased the “Tranquility Select with Natural Tencel” model about 4 months ago and have been very happy with it. I’m not sure what other brands of memory foam were like, but I’m lucky to have one of their authorized resellers nearby so that I got to feel it in store before buying.
I’m not sure if I would recommend the original Pacbed though. It felt very cheap to me when I laid on it. But it will definitely be more comfortable than your Ikea.” -u/sonicice
“I have one from bedinabox.com
They’re actually headquartered in TN, which I thought was neat (that’s where I am, and there is pretty much nothing of value here).
Anyways, as others have said, regular memory foam can collect heat. I got one of the “cooling” models (it usually some sort of gel), and it seems to make a difference. I love mine, and it feels like it will last. I recommend it pretty highly.” -u/drparton21
“This is the one I have and it’s great.” -u/AJayH
“I love my bedinabox mattress. Sits on a Tatami Room frame. Mattress has 20yr warranty and the frame is rock solid, even for heavier people.” -u/scarletphantom
“In general, I like Tuft & Needle. They make good mattress and their line is wide enough to fit the needs of most sleepers. They aren’t my absolute favorite, but still a solid mattress brand by any definition.
I haven’t personally tested the Mint yet, so I cannot say for sure how it compares to others. But based on the T&N mattresses I have tested and looking at their materials and mattress design, there are for sure others that are similar and some that are better (depending on your needs, preferences, and budget).
Since you really like the Mint it might be worth looking at the Ghostbed Luxe, Leesa (original), Amerisleep AS3, Layla (memory foam), Nectar Premier / Premier Copper, BedinaBox Tranquillium, and Zoma (memory foam). All of the above have a similar design. -u/derek-naplab
3. Casper Sleep Original Hybrid – A premium hybrid mattress from a premium brand
- Expensive, but premium
- Durable and reliable
- Innerspring – memory foam Hybrid
- No gel, instead using AirScape technology
- 10 years of warranty
- Trial period of 100 nights
Casper is a well known mattress brand. It sells five mattresses: the Casper Element Pro, the Casper Original, the Casper Original Hybrid, the Casper Wave Hybrid, and the Casper Nova Hybrid. The Casper Original is an all foam mattress, while the Casper Original Hybrid is an innerspring – memory foam hybrid mattress, so make sure you don’t make a mistake while buying. The Casper Original Hybrid mattress has ranked really well in Consumer Reports 2023. Casper doesn’t use fiberglass in its mattresses, instead opting for silica as a flame retardant. The mattresses are all CertiPUR-US certified.
The mattress comes in 6 sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King. The mattress starts at $1100 (for the Twin size variant) and goes up to $1770 (for the California King variant). The Twin size variant weighs 53 lbs while the Cal. King size weighs 114 lbs. The mattress is 11 inches thick. Under the mattress cover, it has three layers: 2 layers of foam and a base layer of innerspring coils. The foam layer at the top features what Casper likes to call the AirScape Technology. The AirScape layer is highly perforated, which enables air flow to keep the mattress cool. All this because the mattress doesn’t feature gel infused memory foam, instead just using polyurethane foam in its top layer.
The mattress has Zoned support, which relieves pressure on different parts of the body. It helps the mattress to be softer around the shoulders and firmer around the hips, waist and lower back. This is achieved by three different zones of slightly differing firmness. This makes it a great choice for back sleepers or for people with back pain. The mattress has great edge support too, thanks to a firm border all around the mattress. This also makes the mattress more durable and reliable over the long term.
Casper provides a 10 year limited warranty too, provided you buy from an authorized retailer. Casper claims that the mattress cover is made of 57 recycled bottles. However, the cover isn’t waterproof, and would therefore not protect your mattress from stains and accidental spills. Casper also sells a waterproof mattress cover to solve that problem, but you would need to buy it separately. The mattress also comes with a trial period of a hundred nights, when you can test the mattress thoroughly and judge whether it’s suitable for you. If you don’t like it, you can return the mattress and get your refund.
- Extremely durable
- Environmentally friendly cover made of recycled bottles
- Good edge support
- Perforated foam used in top layer for breathability and cooling
- No gel for cooling
“We have a Casper (I was showing the site to my husband to mock the vertical-scroll layout that every single “cut out the middleman” online company has, and he decided we needed one…sucker). I actually really like it–it’s firmer than we would have bought in a store, but it doesn’t sleep warm and we always sleep well on it.” -u/Gluestick05
“Update: After sleeping on this for a few nights I have been very impressed. This is my first bed in a box or foam mattress of any kind – we switched from a Sterns & Foster plush mattress from around 2013 that was a queen to this one in a King. It took a few days for it to air out and the foam/chemical smell to subside.
Like someone else, I chatted with Casper customer service and asked them about this one and they said it was very similar to their original Casper Hybrid but with some small differences – another poster said they told them it was a cooling layer, my Casper rep didnt say that specifically.
For context, I am 6’2” 215 lbs with bad lower back problems and my wife is 5’5” 140 lbs. I sleep mostly on my side and this has plenty of give for me sleeping on my side while still offering some support. This is labeled as a ‘Medium’ mattress and I would definitely label it on the soft side of medium – probably a 3 or 4 on firmness scale of 1-10. The February 2020 Consumer Reports that had the original Casper Hybrid ranked 2nd for their innersprings ($1500 or less) rated this as a 3 as well so I think its very similar to that original Casper Hybrid based on this. Overall very comfortable and doesn’t sleep very hot either – my wife tends to sleep like an oven and she hasn’t mentioned it sleeping hot.
I’ll have to see if this stands the test of time but I am very happy now with this purchase for $1k.” -u/Maverick3122
“I would give Casper a shot. I’ve had a queen sized bed for about six months now and no complaints.
They also give you an 100 day trial to test it out and if you don’t like it, they will have someone come and pick it up for free and you’ll get a refund.
You really can’t lose with this :)” -u/Snipetimus
“I have a California King Casper mattress. It’s pretty nice. I guess the memory foam mattresses feel more luxurious, but I like my bed on the firm side. Plus the price and convenience is great.” -u/katashscar
4. Casper Sleep Wave Hybrid – A latex hybrid option
- Highly expensive
- Highly durable and reliable
- Innerspring – memory foam – latex foam Hybrid
- Gel pods for cooling
- AirScape technology
- 10 years of warranty
- Trial period of 100 nights
- Snow Technology
Even though memory foam mattresses are very popular, there are plenty of reasons to hate memory foam mattresses, such as the heat trapping nature of memory foam. For those who don’t like memory foam mattresses, latex is a good option.
Casper currently sells five mattresses: the Casper Element Pro, the Casper Original, the Casper Original Hybrid, the Casper Wave Hybrid, and the Casper Nova Hybrid. However, it used to sell two more: the Casper Nova and the Casper Wave, which are still available on some third party online markets. The Casper Wave is an all foam mattress, while the Casper Wave Hybrid is an innerspring – memory foam – latex foam hybrid mattress, so make sure you don’t get confused between them.
The mattress comes in 6 sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King. Further, the Casper Wave Hybrid comes in two versions: one with “Snow Technology,” and one without. The mattress starts at $1500 (for the Twin size variant) and goes up to $3000 (for the California King variant). Opting for the Snow Technology variant increases the price by around $500. The Twin size variant weighs 70 lbs while the Cal. King size weighs 143 lbs. The mattress is 13 inches thick.
Under the mattress cover, the standard variant has 5 layers. The 1 inch thick top layer is made of perforated AirScape foam with a thin coating of cooling gel. Below that comes a 1.5 inches thick perforated latex foam layer with AirScape technology. After that comes a 1.5 inches thick perforated memory foam layer with pressure zoning. Below that comes a 1.5 inch transition layer made with gel pods and foam. It has upto 78 gel pods for providing you better support. Finally, the 7 inch base support layer is made of innerspring coils wrapped in thick polyurethane foam.
The Casper Wave Hybrid Snow variant has 6 layers. The top layer is a QuickCool Cover made of foam infused with Phase Change Material. Phase Change Materials absorb or release appreciable amounts of energy at phase transition, and therefore are great for temperature regulation. Below that there’s a 1 inch AirScape layer made of perforated foam coated with gel. Then there are 6 HeatDelete bands, which are basically thermal bands made of graphite, which direct heat away from your body. These are attached to an AirScape perforated latex foam layer which is 1.5 inches thick. Below that comes a 1.5 inches thick perforated memory foam layer with pressure zoning, followed by a 1.5 inches thick transition layer with upto 78 gel pods for support and pressure relief. At the bottom, there’s a 7 inch support base layer made of spring coils enclosed in a thick layer of high density polyurethane foam. Casper claims that you can sleep 6 degrees cooler with Snow technology.
The mattress has Zoned support Max to relieve pressure on different parts of the body. Unlike Zoned Support, which has three zones with differing levels of firmness to support your body, Zoned Support Max takes it one step further by continuous zones instead of discrete ones. This makes it a great choice for back sleepers or for people with back pain. The mattress has great edge support too, thanks to a firm border all around the mattress. This also makes the mattress more durable and reliable over the long term.
The mattress comes with a 10 year limited warranty. Casper claims that the mattress cover is made of upto 121 recycled bottles. The mattress also comes with a trial period of a hundred nights, when you can test the mattress thoroughly and judge whether it’s suitable for you. If you don’t like it, you can return the mattress and get your refund.
- Extremely durable.
- Environmentally friendly cover made of recycled bottles.
- Excellent edge support.
- Excellent pressure relief.
- 3 layers of open cell perforated foam with AirScape Technology.
- May not be firm enough for some people.
- Heavier than many other mattresses in this list, which may make it difficult to move the bed.
“I love my Casper mattress. Besides being a very good price, the 100 day trial is awesome plus they will finance you for no interest (really literally no interest) so you can pay it off in bits. If you’re moving, you’re already strapped for cash probably so any little bit helps.
The latex foam on top makes it sleep less hot than a memory foam mattress and feels more like a spring mattress, more give. It’s firm, but still has some squish so suits someone who sleeps at all angles very well.
I’m super happy with mine and even if I replace it in a few years, it was $800 or so so I don’t feel like I spent a fucking fortune on a shitty mattress and can’t just get rid of it.” -u/HeyYoEowyn
“Looks like Caspar is a hybrid latex foam/memory foam bed, which bodes well.
I have been through two memory foam mattresses. Both were really hot. The first one failed within 5 years (though was luckily under warranty). The second one was better,but my back problems had gotten SO BAD on the memory foam, even with the replacement, I was in tears and sleeping on the floor until I could get a new mattress.
I went the way of Talalay Latex and have never looked back. It has the springiness/feeback of a more traditional mattress, but the softness and gentle contouring I actually liked from the memory foam. So I am imagining the combo would be quite good.
I recommend full talaylay latex to everyone, as it has been miraculous for me. But looking into the Caspar, it seems like a nice option!” -u/TribalDancer
“I had the Casper wave hybrid for a month before I returned it. I have lower back pain often but sleeping on the wave hybrid was wonderful and I never woke up with any issues. The month I had it was almost perfect, even the first night was pleasurable.
I ended up returning it because I spoke with a few mattress experts in my area who said the memory foam on Casper is not the highest quality and they knew of people who complained a year out from purchase. Foam breaks down faster than other materials like latex and the lower the quality, the less use you’ll get out of it.
I opted for a medium latex mattress that I am loving just as much. It’s not as spongy as the Casper which I do miss, but it has more stability for my back and I feel good knowing the materials will last me longer than a foam mattress.” -u/Blocguy
5. Tuft & Needle Original Mattress – From a brand that has stood the test of time
- Value for money
- 9.5 inches thick
- Not ideal for heavier people
- 10 year warranty
- Trial period of 100 nights
Tuft & Needle is a competitor to Casper in the mattress market. It sells three mattresses: the Tuft & Needle Original, the Tuft & Needle Mint, and the Tuft & Needle Hybrid. The first two are memory foam mattresses, while the last is an innerspring – memory foam hybrid. With that said, the Tuft & Needle Mint is a more premium and reliable version of the Tuft & Needle Original, even though both are memory foam mattresses. It has won its position in the list of best mattresses by Consumer Reports 2023. However, it’s also very expensive. The Tuft & Needle Original starts at around $650, while the Tuft & Needle Mint starts at $1100. A jump of $450 becomes hard to justify for just a bit of more durability and edge support, and less motion transfer. This is why the Mint has moved to number 8.
The Tuft & Needle Original comes in 6 sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King. It is 9.5 inches thick. The Twin size variant weighs 50 lbs while the California King variant weighs 94 lbs. The mattress is constructed with two layers of memory foam, encased in a soft knit mattress cover. The top layer is 3 inches thick. It is made of “T&N Adaptive foam,” which Tuft & Needle claims to have invented alongside “top American chemists,” and is more durable and breathable. The foam is infused with graphite and gel, which helps you cool down. The bottom layer is a 6.5 inches thick support layer made of open cell foam, which further helps in cooling. The mattress cover is made of 35% micro polyamide and 65% polyester. It is not washable.
The mattress has pressure zoning, which helps you release pressure around your shoulders and hips. Tuft & Needle claims that the T&N Adaptive foam provides a balanced support and pressure relief mechanism, making it ideal for all kinds of sleepers. The mattress is medium – firm. However, it is firmer than the Tuft & Needle Mint mattress. The mattress is also relatively thin, standing at only 9.5 inches. This mattress is, therefore, not meant for heavier individuals. Don’t go for this mattress if you weigh more than 220 lbs.
Tuft & Needle suggests you not remove the mattress cover. In case of any accidental spills or stains, it recommends you to spot clean only. The mattress has a CertiPUR-US certification and a GREENGUARD Gold certification. It comes with a 10 year warranty and a 100 night trial. The mattress is generally highly durable, however, some customers have reported softening of the mattress overtime. That’s something you might want to consider. If you face any problems, you can easily contact Tuft & Needle and they will help you. Tuft & Needle is known for its great customer service, so that’s a plus.
- Value for money.
- Amazing customer service.
- A lot of cooling mechanisms for temperature control.
- Lighter than many other mattresses in this list, which is especially noticeable for larger sized variants.
- GREENGUARD Gold certification.
- May not be as reliable and durable as the Tuft & Needle Mint mattress.
- Doesn’t have 2 inch mint foam offered in the Mint mattress, which reduces motion transfer.
- Edge support is not so good.
- This mattress is not for larger or heavier individuals.
“I have a Tuft and Needle mattress, it’s more comfortable than any inner spring I’ve owned. I haven’t noticed that it’s warmer than other mattresses. I would definitely recommend it.
Quality memory foam will be firm enough to spring back up and retain its shape when you aren’t lying on it. I imagine Amazon has an assortment of mattresses, some of which are probably not very good quality. Find one with good reviews and a good reputation.” -u/peace_and_long_life
“I have had a full size T&N original since June 2017 – bought it when I moved into my house.
I am 250lbs and a side sleeper. I find it to be medium-firm/firm which I like. I have not been strict on rotating my mattress around, so my bed has developed a bit of a dip. it is not noticeable to the eye, but when I am in bed I notice it’s softer where I always sleep.
I find it to be still comfortable and I think it’s a good mattress. It’s no where near where I would say ‘OMG, I need a new mattress!’ I want a bigger bed, which is why I keep stalking here to see opinions 🙂 Someone asked me if I would buy T&N again and I would, yes. But I am like everyone else and am thinking there’s a holy grail of mattresses out there somewhere and maybe some random review in r/mattress will help me find it.” -u/Gingerstop
“I got a tuft & needle mattress Friday I had two pillow top mattresses one in2011 and 2017 the pillow top mattresses I owned started sinking the springs were popping up through the mattress I owned a memory foam before in 2015 I’m very happy with my new tuft and needle mattress I’ve owned it 2 days I have gotten the best night’s with this new mattress don’t buy a pillow top mattress they don’t have a guarantee this mattress has a10 year warranty” -u/Suitable_Tip2649
6. Sleep Innovations Shiloh – Best midrange mattress
- 2 thickness variants: 12 inches and 14 inches
- Air channels for 14 inch variant
- No gel
- 10 year warranty
- Available in 5 sizes; no Twin XL
Sleep Innovations is known for its high quality midrange mattresses. The company sells 6 mattresses: Marley, Shiloh, Hudson, Quinn, Ellis, and Skyler. Sleep Innovations Marley is the cheapest mattress option and features a gel layer. It’s also not very durable. Sleep Innovations Shiloh doesn’t feature a gel layer, and is still more expensive. However, it is made of better materials and made to last longer. The Sleep Innovations Shiloh mattress is an all foam mattress, and further comes in two variants: the 12 inch variant and the 14 inch variant.
The mattress comes in 5 sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, and California King. For the 12 inch variant, the mattress starts at $369 for the Twin size variant and goes up to $549 for the California King variant. The 12 inch Twin size variant weighs 45.5 pounds while the California King size variant weighs 94.2 pounds. The 12 inch variant simply has 2 layers of foam: 2.5 inch memory foam layer at the top and a 9.5 inch high density polyurethane foam layer at the bottom. Since the 12 inch variant has neither gel nor any perforated foam layer, heat trapping may be a problem. If you choose to go with the 12 inch variant, you may want to add a gel mattress topper on the mattress to solve the heating problem.
The 14 inch variant starts at $429 for the Twin size variant and goes up to $629. The 14 inch Twin size variant weighs 50.4 pounds while the California King size variant weighs 104.3 pounds. The 14 inch variant has 3 layers of foam: 2.5 inch memory foam layer at the top, a 2.5 air channeled foam in the middle, and a 9 inch high density polyurethane foam layer at the bottom. The layer of air channeled foam helps in better airflow, which cools the mattress down and solves the overheating problem present in the 12 inch variant.
You get a 10 year warranty for the mattress, which is pretty much the industrial standard. However, you may not be eligible for warranty if you buy the mattress from an unauthorized retailer. There are only two authorized retailers at the moment: Amazon and Walmart. The mattress is CertiPUR-US certified, just like all other Sleep Innovations mattresses, and is therefore free of harmful chemicals.
- Suits both lighter and heavier individuals.
- May be less durable than the more premium mattresses in this list.
- The 12 inch variant lacks any form of heat dissipation mechanism.
“My buddy slept on a Sleep Innovations Shiloh 12″ for years. He got married 6 years ago, and bought a new Shiloh in 14″. His old one was given to his brother. Both are still being used.
BUT – neither my buddy, his wife, or his brother have back problems, neck problems, they are all fairly short and light, and have narrow shoulders. So… none of them need good support or contouring. Your mileage may vary.” -u/DeathKoil
“I can’t comment on their mattresses, but I have a Sleep Innovations memory foam topper (not gel) that is over 15 years old and is still in great shape, and as comfortable as the day I bought it. It’s in a travel trailer all year so is subject to extreme heat and cold. I also have a pillow from the same company. The topper probably has 300-400 nights sleep on it.
I like the topper a lot better than a newer gel- infused Novaform topper (too soft, gave it away).” -u/Dotsgirl22
“Sleep innovations on Amazon. I get the Shiloh mattress because it’s medium-firm, the other mattress is too soft for me, and the “cool-top” mattress didn’t feel like a memory foam mattress. It’s completely spoiled me and I hate almost every other mattress; everyone who has slept on it has commented on how super comfortable it is.” -u/gravitydriven
7. Tempur Pedic ProAdapt – Medically tested, ultra premium mattress
- Custom materials used for better comfort
- Split versions available
- 4 firmness versions
- 6 different sizes
- Warranty of 10 years
If money isn’t a problem for you, and you want the absolute best mattress money can possibly buy, go for a Tempur Pedic. Tempur Pedic mattresses are known for being incredibly expensive, and the cost may not be justifiable for a vast majority of people. However, Tempur Pedic mattresses last very long, and are all medically tested. If you have some serious back issues, Tempur Pedic might be the best option for you. Tempur Pedic sells 3 mattresses: the Tempur Pedic Adapt series, the Tempur Pedic Breeze series, and the Tempur Pedic Cloud Prima. The Tempur Pedic Adapt has further three categories: the standard Adapt, ProAdapt, and LuxeAdapt.
The Tempur Pedic ProAdapt mattress comes in 4 different variants in terms of firmness: Soft, Medium Hybrid, Medium, and Firm. The mattress comes in 6 sizes: Twin, Twin Long, Full, Queen, King, and California King. For the King and California King mattresses, you also have a split variant and a regular variant. Split variants of these mattresses split these mattresses into two halves, so that you choose the firmness for each of the sides separately. This is especially useful when you sleep with a partner who has a different preference for firmness in a mattress than you do. Thus, you get a wide range of options for this mattress, which aren’t available in other mattresses. You can choose your own firmness for the mattress, and can even choose two different firmness levels! However, this comes at a premium. The mattress starts at $2849 for the Twin size variant and goes up to $5698 for the Split King or Split California King variant.
The soft version of the mattress has two layers: a TEMPUR-ES comfort layer, and a TEMPUR-APR support layer. ES stands for Extra Soft, while APR stands for Advanced Pressure Relief. The Medium Hybrid version has three layers: a TEMPUR-ES comfort layer on the top, a TEMPUR-APR support layer in the middle and a base layer of more than a thousand spring coils to provide structural support to the mattress as well as a good edge support. The Medium version has an Original TEMPUR comfort layer on the top and a TEMPUR-APR support layer at the bottom. Original TEMPUR refers to the material used by NASA to absorb the g force of astronauts in spaceflight, further modified by Tempur Pedic to make a comfortable mattress for sleep. Finally, the Firm version of the mattress uses a TEMPUR-APR comfort layer and an Original TEMPUR support layer.
The mattress has excellent resistance to motion transfer, which Tempur Pedic terms as “motion cancellation.” Tempur Pedic’s excellent motion cancellation is exactly what made it a well known brand, with the famous commercial which featured a woman jumping on the mattress (made of Original TEMPUR material) beside a wine glass kept on the same mattress, which didn’t fall or spill. Tempur Pedic still talks about that commercial, calling it the wine glass test, to demonstrate the resistance to motion transfer. If you’re highly sensitive to motion and any form of disturbance in the mattress wakes you up, sleeping with your partner can be a big problem. But not with this mattress.
Since the material used varies based on the firmness option chosen, the weight of the mattress varies too. The Twin size version of the mattress weighs 52 – 69 lbs, while the California King size weighs 106 – 151 lbs. If you choose to have a split mattress, the Split King version weighs 104 – 138 lbs and the Split California King version weighs 112 – 149 lbs.
The mattress comes with a warranty of 10 years, provided you buy it new and from an authorized retailer. The mattress is only compatible with a flat foundation or a platform bed. It is not compatible with box springs and is also not supposed to be used on the floor, which will void the warranty.
- Custom materials for maximum comfort.
- You can choose how firm your mattress will be.
- You can choose to have different firmness options for different sides.
- Good for those with back pain issues.
- Extreme resistance to motion transfer.
- Highly expensive.
- Not compatible with box springs.
“I had one of the old school TPs. You know, the big block of foam with a brown cover from the infomercials with a lady jumping on the bed without spilling the wine? It wasn’t the very first model, but it was from before TP’s line exploded to what it is now.
I paid about $2,500 or so for a queen, I think. I had it for at least 12-13 years. Much to my regret I did not use a waterproof mattress cover on top of the cover they provide, and I think that caused it to break down faster than it otherwise would have. And it was hot as a MoFo and impossible to move.
But I also slept better than I ever had. I loved that bed, and I found it worth every penny that I paid for it, even though it didn’t hold up for the 20 years I had heard.
So I feel that one was worth its price. These days a TP is SO much more expensive. They have priced me out at this point. If you have it and you can spend it, it’ll likely be a high quality mattress, but only you can know if it’s worth the price for you. They are also a different kind of sleep, for sure. It’ll depend on what you’re coming from and if TP has a bed that’s right for you. COVID makes this incredibly hard (if not impossible) but if you can find a showroom I would go and spend a solid half hour or more laying on the bed in the position you sleep in.
Bottom line: If I could afford one I’d probably still be sleeping on a TP.” -u/HarryPotterGeek
“I’ve had a proadapt medium for about a year now and really like it. My wife and I had an expensive sterns and foster that was good for about five or six years, then bought a sealy posterpedic (based on Consumer Reports recommendations) that started sagging within first year (wife is ~120 pounds and I’m 185). Was super frustrated with the Sealy experience because there’s no reason it should have been sagging so early. Ponied up for the Tempurpedic because of reputation and seemingly strong warranty support. Tempurpedic is really comfortable and is holding up really well – still feels like new. Wife and I are mainly side sleepers if that makes a difference.” -u/Routyroute
“7 years on from my first Tempurpedic and I must say I’ve been sleeping happily of them.
What I’m not sure is, if at the time that I purchased my Tempurpedic 7 years ago, had I been in worse financial circumstances and had had to settle for a much cheaper mattress, whether I would have been equally happy these past 7 years.
In other words, I don’t know if there are matresses out there that give you 90% of the comfort for maybe 1/4 of cost.” -u/sbrueding
8. Tuft & Needle Mint Mattress – The most premium and reliable memory foam mattress
- Use of green gel instead of blue gel
- Better edge support
- Available in 6 sizes
Tuft & Needle Mint is the more premium version of the Tuft & Needle Original. It has earned its position in the list of best mattresses in Consumer Reports 2023. The mattress comes in 6 sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King. It is 11.5 inches thick. The Twin size variant weighs 50 lbs while the California King variant weighs 100 lbs. The mattress starts at $1100 for the Twin size variant and goes up to $1950 for the King and California King variant.
The mattress has 3 layers. The top layer is made of 3 inches of open cell foam infused with graphite and gel for better cooling. The Tuft & Needle Mint uses 30% more graphite in this top layer than the Tuft & Needle Original. The middle layer is a 2 inches thick Mint layer, made of open cell foam and ceramic gel beads for further cooling. Tuft & Needle claims that these ceramic gel beads, also known as green gel, have five times better cooling effect than the “blue gel” used in the Tuft & Needle Original Mattress. The base layer is made of 6.5 inches of high density polyurethane foam.
The Mint layer does add additional cushioning to the mattress, however, the presence of ceramic beads prevents you from sinking in the mattress. This makes it ideal for not only lighter people, but also heavier and larger people. Moreover, the Mint layer also acts as a transition layer, and therefore results in less motion transfer than the Tuft & Needle Original Mattress. The Mint Mattress is also softer than the Original Mattress, with Tuft & Needle claiming that it’s the softest mattress it offers.
The mattress cover is removable and machine washable, unlike most other mattresses in this list. Just unzip, take the cover off, wash it, dry it, get the cover on, and zip it again. The mattress also has good edge support due to reinforced construction of the support edges. The mattress is CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold certified. The mattress has a 10 year limited warranty and a 100 night sleep trial.
- Better cooling.
- Good edge support.
- Can support heavier individuals.
- It may be too soft for some people.
“I have a Tuft & Needle Mint and I love it! I find most memory foam mattresses a bit too soft and way too warm, so this has been a good switch for me. More medium firm than super soft and sleeps cool” -u/slothandcats
“I just replaced my shitty full-sized CostCo brand innerspring mattress that’s I’ve had since high school with a queen Tuft and Needle Mint and an Article bed frame.
I am loving it.” -u/VanillaFlavoredCake
“I am a side sleeper and just got a new mattress. Purple Hybrid 4 was the most recommended of the “new mattress companies” but I couldn’t bring myself to spend $4,000 on a mattress I had never tried.
I went with my original choice from all the years I’ve been contemplating, and got a Tuft & Needle Mint. I’m not very heavy so I added a topper and squishy pad, and I absolutely love it. At some point I am going to go back to just the mattress and try with knit sheets directly on the mattress, because any pad or cotton sheet adds just a bit too much firmness for me.
I got the mattress during their anniversary sale last month, they often have sales around holidays as well.
I was a little worried about getting an untried mattress but I absolutely love it. Keep in mind for any memory foam mattress you will need a supportive base, I got a short metal box spring with wide slats (and narrow spacing) made by Zinus.
As another poster mentioned, r/mattress can be helpful but I also found too much information sometimes.” -u/blackcatspurplewalls
“I got the tuft & needle mint mattress and it’s very good if you like a firmer mattress. Have used it for 2 years now and no divot at all (and I’m 250+lbs). I had a bed-in-a-box previously that also developed a bad divot within the first year that got worse over time. So at least so far, the T&N seems to be holding up a lot better. It is definitely on the firmer side of the spectrum, though. It also doesn’t sleep hot – that would be a dealbreaker for me as I can’t stand a hot & sweaty feeling while trying to sleep.
That being said, there are very few mattresses that are BIFL, save for very high end spring mattresses. No foam mattress are going to last more than ~10 years. -u/madmax_br5
9. Leesa Legend Hybrid – An alternative to Casper Hybrids
- Innerspring – memory foam hybrid
- Recycled springs
- Quality cover made of natural materials
- Good responsiveness
- Warranty of 10 years
- Trial period of 100 nights
If you’re not a big fan of Casper’s mattresses, but still want a luxury hybrid mattress, the Leesa Legend Hybrid might be the best choice for you. Leesa makes 5 mattresses for adults and 3 for kids. The kids mattresses include the Youth Mattress, the Trindle Mattress, and the Kids Mattress. The adult mattresses include the Leesa Original, the Leesa Original Hybrid, the Leesa Sapira Hybrid, the Leesa Legend Hybrid, and the Leesa Studio.
The Leesa Legend Hybrid comes in 5 sizes: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King. It starts at $1599 for the Twin size variant and goes up to $2299 for the California King size variant. The Twin XL size version of the mattress weighs 81 pounds, while the California King size version weighs 149 pounds. The mattress is 12 inches thick.
The mattress cover is made of 100% Organic cotton and Merino wool, which regulates the temperature and helps you sleep well. Under the cover lies a 6 layered design. The top layer is a 1 inch thick perforated foam layer designed for better breathability and cooling. Below that lies a 1 inch thick memory foam layer, followed by a 1.5 inch thick zoned support layer which has three zones with slightly different firmness, helping to relieve pressure near the shoulders, hip and back area. The zoned support layer is made of more than 756 small pocketed springs to relieve pressure on different parts of your body. Below that lies a 1 inch thick transition layer for further support to the spine. Below that lies a 6 inch thick layer of more than 1041 innerspring coils for providing structural support as well as good responsiveness. At the bottom lies a 1 inch base support layer made of high density polyurethane foam.
The mattress comes with a 10 year limited warranty and a 100 night trial. Some people have reported softening of their mattresses after a few years, and the mattress faces some legitimate durability concerns. However, if you would still like to avoid Casper, going for the Leesa Hybrid is a better option than the Tuft & Needle Hybrid, which has a bit more exaggerated quality control issue. Make sure you buy the mattress from an authorized retailer to be under warranty just in case.
- Luxurious and comfortable.
- A good fit for all kinds of sleepers.
- Good cooling mechanism.
- Durability issues.
“Like many of you, I read this subreddit trying to find the perfect mattress, eventually got overwhelmed and fatigued by the choices and just pulled the trigger on the Leesa Legend medium-firm hybrid. It was on sale at Costco for 1250, and with their return policy it was worth a shot. I’ve had the mattress for two weeks so far.
I’m 5’8” 140 pounds and sleep 70/30 on my back/side, so wanted something a bit firmer but that was still comfortable for side sleeping. I think the Legend’s double coils are probably excessive, but I find the responsiveness and (hopefully) longevity to be worth it. The top foam layer is soft and comfortable, I just barely sink in and feel like I get some pressure relief, but no hot cradle feeling.
I will say the organic wool/cotton cover is just marketing, it’s a polyester blend and while comfortable, should not at all be a selling point. I probably wouldn’t purchase this mattress at the ~2000 price point directly from Leesa, and even the regular price of 1500 at Costco felt steep, but for 1250 I feel very happy with my purchase.” –u/sonllama
“I brought a Leesa Mattress, Queen a full year ago. And I freaking love it !! Amazon delivered the body size box right to the back door and I’ve been in love with the mattress ever since. Gonna buy one for my kid when they out grow their crib mattress.
Edit: I paid 815 for mine” -u/9babydill
“Very good. I also got the leesa hybrid a couple of weeks ago. Like you I’m 5’11, 190lbs, mostly side sleeper (occasional side). I’m really liking it so far, although it took me a few days to adjust.” -u/Ok-Supermarket-1414
“For anyone also considering the Leesa Hybrid, I can report my experience was very similar to OP’s during the first year of ownership. My fiancé and I were in disbelief that a mattress could provide so much support and offer such sound sleep. It was definitely a game changer at first.
3 years into ownership- the game has changed again. The firmness of the memory foam has degraded much faster than originally anticipated. There’s now a noticeable soft spot around where my hips and lower back typically lie, that cause my hips to sink into the mattress in a very unnatural way, leading to poor sleep quality and excruciating back pain.
Just want to provide an honest review. I really loved this bed at the beginning, but if spending $2,000 on a mattress every 3 years is not your thing you may want to look to products with more long-term success stories. After some quick googling it seems my experience is not uncommon.” -u/DUNGAROO
10. Amerisleep mattress – All foam mattress, but variable firmness
- Various levels of firmness
- Comfortable cover
- More environmentally friendly, plant based foam
- Affordable pricing
- 20 years warranty
- 100 nights sleep trial
Amerisleep is a very straightforward brand. No complex names for mattresses or hyped up names for simple features. It straight up hands you over the options to get a memory foam mattress. Amerisleep memory foam mattress has 5 variants: AS1, AS2, AS3, AS4, and AS5. AS1 is the firmest and AS5 is the softest, with the rest transitioning from firm to soft. The mattress comes in 6 sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King.
The AS5 mattress has a Celiant cover, which Amerisleep claims is an advanced fabric made of 13 thermoactive minerals. The mattress is 14 inches thick.
Under the cover lies 4 layers of foam. The top layer is perforated for cooling, and is made of Amerisleep’s proprietary Bio-Pur foam. Unlike traditional memory foam, the Bio-Pur foam is partly made of plant based oils and fewer petrochemicals. This makes the foam overall a more eco friendly option. Below that lies a very responsive Active Flex layer which bounces really fast and snaps back to its shape quickly. Below that lies a zoned transition foam for relieving pressure. Finally, there’s a high density foam support layer to provide structural stability and edge support. It starts at $1449.
The AS4 has a medium – soft feel, and is 12 inches thick. It has a Refresh cover, which Amerisleep claims turns body heat to far infrared energy, which helps in blood circulation. Amerisleep also claims that the cover is made of a fabric with extremely high energy transfer capabilities. Under the cover lies a 4 inch thick perforated Bio-Pur foam cooling layer, followed by a 1 inch thick transition foam layer and a base support layer 7 inches thick. It starts at $1049.
The AS3 has a medium feel, and is 12 inches thick. It has the same Refresh cover as the AS4. Under the cover, it has three layers. The top layer is a 3 inch Bio-Pur foam layer, the transition layer is 2 inches thick, and the base layer is 7 inches thick. The mattress starts at $849.
The AS2 is a medium – firm mattress and is 12 inches thick. It has the same Refresh cover for cooling you down and improving circulation. The AS2 has three layers: a 2 inch thick Bio-Pur foam layer at the top, followed by a 3 inch transition layer, and a 7 inch high density foam base support layer. It starts at $749.
The AS1 is the firmest mattress in the lineup. It is 10 inches thick. It has the same Refresh cover used in the previous mattresses, but has only two layers under the cover. The mattress has a 2 inch thick Bio-Pur foam layer on the top and an 8 inch thick base support layer on the bottom. It starts at $649.
The mattress is CertiPUR-US certified. AmeriSleep backs its mattresses with a 20 year warranty, which is at par with BedInABox. It also offers a trial of a hundred nights. If you don’t like it, you can simply return it and get the refund.
- Many different variants for choosing the firmness
- Long warranty of 20 years.
- The thickening of the comfort layer from AS2 to AS4 is also met with shrinking of the transition layer which makes the mattress less stable for heavier individuals.
“My spouse and I bought a couple of beds from Costco but were always disappointed in their quality. (last one was the sterns and foster version)
We went with a bed in a box bed from Amerisleep and have been really happy with it. If I was to do it again (even better if you’re in the PNW) I would buy a stumptown mattress.” -u/Hackanddash
“Looking at memory foam mattresses, those are usually the best certifications you can find. There will always been some form of VOCs and flame retardants with them, but those certifications definitely minimize them. Just be careful, as they won’t ever be nonexistent in memory foam beds, so consider this if you’re really sensitive to them.
With the fiberglass, however, everything I’m seeing about the brand is that they have zero fiberglass, which is good! (I always double check what customer service says if I can; the mattress business is all marketing nowadays).
The only thing I can say is take note of things when you get the mattress, even with those certifications. The biggest thing is the smell. If the mattress has a really strong smell that needs to “air out” over a period of time, that’s VOCs you’re smelling. They never stop airing out, but you get used to the smell and don’t notice it anymore after some time. This is really common with memory foam.
If fiberglass is the biggest concern, Amerisleep should suffice for you, but with VOCs and flame retardants, you will find those in every memory foam mattress to some degree. Those certifications definitely minimize them, but do not fully eliminate them, so if you’re really sensitive, memory foam may not be the best option.
Like I tend to say at work, you know your body best! If memory foam is most comfortable for you and works best, then Amerisleep sounds like a great option for no fiberglass and reduced VOCs and flame retardants!” -u/sxphisticated
“I love Costco but I’ve struggled finding a soft enough mattress to relieve pressure — I’m also a side sleeper. We ended up going with the Amerisleep as5 hybrid and it’s great so far.” -u/Comprehensive_Dog854
Best Mattress Without Memory Foam
Best Japanese Futon Mattress Reddit
Last update on 2023-03-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Leave a Reply